I would say chaotic maul, but Dharok's is so much better. Same idea for rapier or longsword. Dharok's is just incredibly dominant for melee. If you don't mind knowing your chaotic maul is mostly inferior to Dharok's at low health, go ahead and get it. DH-ing is kinda situational, but really it's almost always worth it. If Dharok's doesn't get nerfed any time soon, your next best choice might be a chaotic crossbow. But dual wielding seems kinda crappy, so you might have to settle for shield-ranging with your cxb. That being said, 2h ranged weapons (2h everything really) is pretty much the best. So maybe you could get a chaotic staff? However it's not a big upgrade over the staff of light, and seeing as the SoL not only is non-degrading, it also costs 300k and saves 1/8 of your runes, it might actually be inferior if you're poverty tier. And supposedly staves only affect auto-attack damage, unlike other 2h weaponry, so in theory a wand would give the same DPS. But you have to realize, magic autocasts have a tendency to sneak their way in between abilities, so auto-attack damage is probably the most important for magic (makes sense because you're expected to use runes). Then there's always the option of shields... Nah. I think I should just stop now, I'm getting a bit ranty.