Shattered Heart Discussion

[9276wizard]

So does the second time you try to build the statue give more exp than the first time? And is it any harder to find the rocks the second time?

[Hajutze]

So does the second time you try to build the statue give more exp than the first time? And is it any harder to find the rocks the second time?

It took me literally 2 coifs for my crafting stones (both of them :D) so I'd say the drop rate is the same. And the exp you receive is from a formula ... so I'd say it is the same =/

[Saunamajuri]

So, from what I`ve read, you need to buil the statue fully 30 times to obtain all of the replica statue pieces. This should mean that total of 900 pieces must be found in order to get them all.

[Den]

So, from what I`ve read, you need to buil the statue fully 30 times to obtain all of the replica statue pieces. This should mean that total of 900 pieces must be found in order to get them all.

 

I prefer to look at it as "I need to collect 30 rocks every week for a while."

It isnt as discouraging. :P

[killmenub]

So, from what I`ve read, you need to buil the statue fully 30 times to obtain all of the replica statue pieces. This should mean that total of 900 pieces must be found in order to get them all.

 

I prefer to look at it as "I need to collect 30 rocks every week for a while."

It isnt as discouraging. :P

I think its pretty lame so I've given up on it already. 30 every day or every 2 days would be much better.

[Grimy_Bunyip]

So, from what I`ve read, you need to buil the statue fully 30 times to obtain all of the replica statue pieces. This should mean that total of 900 pieces must be found in order to get them all.

 

I prefer to look at it as "I need to collect 30 rocks every week for a while."

It isnt as discouraging. :P

Am I only finding it discouraging because of RCing stones?

is anybody else finding that it's taking hours an hours to get just the RCing stones? whereas most other stones are doable in 5-20 minutes?

[joke33]

So, from what I`ve read, you need to buil the statue fully 30 times to obtain all of the replica statue pieces. This should mean that total of 900 pieces must be found in order to get them all.

 

I prefer to look at it as "I need to collect 30 rocks every week for a while."

It isnt as discouraging. :P

Am I only finding it discouraging because of RCing stones?

is anybody else finding that it's taking hours an hours to get just the RCing stones? whereas most other stones are doable in 5-20 minutes?

Try making runes one by one, not full inventories every time.

[HunterDexter]

So, from what I`ve read, you need to buil the statue fully 30 times to obtain all of the replica statue pieces. This should mean that total of 900 pieces must be found in order to get them all.

 

I prefer to look at it as "I need to collect 30 rocks every week for a while."

It isnt as discouraging. :P

Am I only finding it discouraging because of RCing stones?

is anybody else finding that it's taking hours an hours to get just the RCing stones? whereas most other stones are doable in 5-20 minutes?

 

Hmm, rc took me long the 2nd time, but almost everything is taking me longer the second time. My guess is that farm is the most discouraging, is taking me way too long, especially because you have to wait for the growing crops and you can't do anything better.

[Emmentail]

You aren't meant to grind to get these stones every week. They're meant to come about from normal skilling. Set yourself an rc goal and think of the stones are bonuses.

[Grimy_Bunyip]

Try making runes one by one, not full inventories every time.

i've done it both ways, about 2 hours with full RC loads and 2 hours 1 by 1, either way it seems a little ridiculous

 

You aren't meant to grind to get these stones every week. They're meant to come about from normal skilling. Set yourself an rc goal and think of the stones are bonuses.

I mean this is true, but on the other hand, there is some pressure to complete the statue every week. Which is impractical without grinding.

[HunterDexter]

Yeah, I'm only collecting these stones because they are meant to be collected, that they should be gotten by training normally isn't of any importance, because in no way I could be able to rebuild the total statue in our POH that way.

[foofoomagoo]

Does anyone know if serums work for herblore? would be a cheaper alternative

[Hajutze]

Btw when does the "new week" starts ? Monday, exactly 168 hours after you complete it ... any information ?

[xxshady]

I mean this is true, but on the other hand, there is some pressure to complete the statue every week. Which is impractical without grinding.

 

I don't feel any pressure to do skills I wouldn't normally do just because of the stones and some of the extra exp =/

 

Distractions and diversions aren't meant to be goals, they happen as you play the game normally

[yurpsie]

I feel that I'm grinding only for the skills which I don't like (eg. crafting, and runecrafting)

 

Farming does take a while, but if you actually do it in between skills (eg. using explorer's ring), you'll find that you'll eventually get the stones.

[Grimy_Bunyip]

Btw when does the "new week" starts ? Monday, exactly 168 hours after you complete it ... any information ?

1 week hasn't happened yet so nobody knows for sure, but from the images it looks like it will work like tears of guthix

attempting to complete the statue a second time will give you a count of how many days until the next build I believe.

 

I mean this is true, but on the other hand, there is some pressure to complete the statue every week. Which is impractical without grinding.

 

I don't feel any pressure to do skills I wouldn't normally do just because of the stones and some of the extra exp =/

 

Distractions and diversions aren't meant to be goals, they happen as you play the game normally

the thing is with this minigame, if how you play the game normally doesn't coincide with how shattered hearts expects you to play, then it becomes a grind

I used to make wines to train cooking, but that doesnt work with shattered hearts

I used to make air bstaffs to train crafting, but that doesnt work with shattered hearts

mining concentrated gold ores doesn't work from what I hear

neither does superheating gold ores, once again, from what I have heard

Personally I train thieving by pickpocketing, but pyramid plunder is more popular amongst my friends

I prefer to fly fish, but the minigame forces me to net/cage

 

i think that's about it. Many of the skills are perfectly viable as a distraction and diversion

but too many of the skills force players to break away from their preferred training methods, to grind solely for the sake of the minigame, for a reward that they are not informed of.

 

shattered hearts is geared towards the average player. The training methods are those average players use

More efficient and higher level players will find themselves pressured to grind using average training methods they normally would not use.

[lordkafei]

I mean this is true, but on the other hand, there is some pressure to complete the statue every week. Which is impractical without grinding.

 

I don't feel any pressure to do skills I wouldn't normally do just because of the stones and some of the extra exp =/

 

Distractions and diversions aren't meant to be goals, they happen as you play the game normally

 

Yes, but if you have 99s in some of these, you are not as likely to be training them at all. Playing the game normally, I would never get many of these stones.

 

So we are back to grinding.

 

This also leads me to believe this will not be some whiz-bang super fantastic reward, but rather something more midlevel in nature.

[Den]

Does anyone know if serums work for herblore? would be a cheaper alternative

 

Dont think they do. I made like 90 without getting one, switched over to tradable potions and got one after 20 or so.

[foofoomagoo]

Does anyone know if serums work for herblore? would be a cheaper alternative

 

Dont think they do. I made like 90 without getting one, switched over to tradable potions and got one after 20 or so.

 

Yeah did 800 to see no rocks

[lordkafei]

Btw when does the "new week" starts ? Monday, exactly 168 hours after you complete it ... any information ?

 

The game is telling me I can complete the statue again in 4 days (so that would be Thurdsay the 11th).

[Dire_Wolf]

It's bull that you can play normally and get these stones. Play normally could just mean fishing all day for someone. Having the pressure to get these stones each week bugs me.

 

Why? What if the reward is something relevant for a Warrior...

 

And here i was planning to do many Clue scrolls.

[Sy_Accursed]

A non-fighting mage who is part of a purely non-combat D&D...yeah a reward for a warrior is blatently whats coming.

 

I wouldnt be surprised if the full reward is jsut the statue replica

[Jabuli]

Does anyone know if it is possible to get the crafting rocks by making holy symbols?

 

I've made over 500 of them now and haven't got a single rock yet.

[Emmentail]

The Rs Website says Leather or Gold jewelry. So i think no on the silver front. Rs wiki says a better list of things. Like the fact the wildy course also gives you rocks.

[odesa]

Does anyone know if serums work for herblore? would be a cheaper alternative

 

I made about 300 serums, nothing. Made about 50 combat pots and got the first one. I don't think serum 207 works.