December 23, 200619 yr Me and a friend of mine have been debating about this for quite a long time, so i wanna see what fellow Tip.It'ers have to say about it. My friend says scimitars are better than battleaxes since they are faster. I think that b-axes are better since they tend to hit higher numbers and give a better strength bonus (Not to mention that Dragon B-axe has better special than Dragon scimmy, IMO)... So, help us end it once and for all, which is better?
December 23, 200619 yr Scimmy. By far. The extra power of the axe doesn't make up for the speed of the scimmy.
December 23, 200619 yr Scimmy. And that special is good for some things, especially in CW when you're fighting someone who's using melee prayer, you knock it right out if you hit em xD Battle axes are too slow. Scimmy is faster, thus meaning if you can hit fairly high, you'll probably hit higher numbers in x amount of hits than the b axe does in that same amount of time. Wolfy is Officially Retired.I miss you all (Well, mostly my friends n stuff)If you want to talk to me, send me a message, I check the boards daily. :D
December 23, 200619 yr i've always been for the b-axe. it hits hard, and i don't mind that its slow...the damage makes up for it.
December 23, 200619 yr i used to be b-axe now scimmy its just faster and better thanks to mitsubishi64 who made this sig
December 23, 200619 yr Scimitar by far is much better and useful. Battle axes are really slow and don't really hit much more than the scimitar.
December 23, 200619 yr I prefer the long over both, just because of its impressive special. My favorite combo is Battle spec+Attack pot+scim. Scim>Battle because Speed>Power The code in my sig should say 1032 not 0132.
December 23, 200619 yr yep. go for the scimmy. the battleaxe hits high, but for the rune battleaxe (im f2p), it has really low accuracy. the r2h has good accuracy and really high strength. but i still like the scimmy. :thumbsup: Retired from runescape. I will be on every now and then though. :)
December 23, 200619 yr Scimmy, cheaper, faster, cheaper, easier to get, cheaper, and did I mention cheaper? Sorry for being so annoying, but scimmy= 30k, BAxe = approx. 50k?
December 23, 200619 yr Scim. It's not too much of a damage difference, and it's a lot quicker. 122 Combat : 99 Hits : 99 Attack : 99 Strength97/99 Defence : 99 Fletching : 99 Woodcutting
December 23, 200619 yr With rune, I would pick the scimmy. But now that I have been testing the D battle axe, I enjoy it. A reflection is just a distorted reality held by glass and your mind.
December 23, 200619 yr Wow, I always used the battle axe. The battle axe can smash attack, which is a bonus against plates, which is what people generally wear(in pvp anyway). I kinda figured that would make a difference.
December 23, 200619 yr Long swords all the way for me! Oh...this thread is about scimmies and battle axes :shock: ? hm...ehr... go longswords! and scimmies! Add me if you so wish: SwreeTak
December 23, 200619 yr Scims all the way! :mrgreen: Main Account - Max cape achieved 10th September 2011 Noob Account - 2300 total and climbing
December 23, 200619 yr Well, Scimmy I think. The speed is better then the power. Atleast in f2p. The special of the Battleaxe is quite good aswell. "A man's gotta do what a man's gotta do"[Currently playing: K1ll L1f3]
December 23, 200619 yr baxe is only abit more accurate than scimmy scimmy is best short bow is better Hey Nicrune007 , Whats Your Username? 99 Ranged on 2/6/07 99 Hit Points on 9/5/08 99 Defense on 26/4/08 99 Attack on 14/2/09 99 Strength on 25/2/09 99 Slayer on 13/9/09\:D/
December 23, 200619 yr Rune scimitar for me :D The secret of creativity is knowing how to hide your sources.
December 23, 200619 yr the scimmys speed makes up for the lower numbers but a finish blow a battle ax is better at
December 23, 200619 yr Dagger pwns all, 'nuff said. :P I like dagger over scimmy but scimmy over b-axe
December 23, 200619 yr Long swords all the way for me! Oh...this thread is about scimmies and battle axes :shock: ? hm...ehr... go longswords! and scimmies! Heck yeah! Longswords are the uber-ownage! Well... Ummm... I guess scimitars. Sig credit goes to ThruItAll. :D
December 23, 200619 yr yep. go for the scimmy. the battleaxe hits high, but for the rune battleaxe (im f2p), it has really low accuracy. the r2h has good accuracy and really high strength. but i still like the scimmy. :thumbsup: accuracy doesn't depend on the weapon, but on ur attack lvls. i used to like the skimmy, for its speed, but then i got stronger, and went for a little bit of PKing, so got a battle ax. it all depends on wat u wanta kill. goin PKing, use battle ax, going to kill some beasties, scimmy. i currently have 1 of each, rune, WOOT! :thumbsup:
Create an account or sign in to comment