I would chose the Phat just cause its worth so much, but if they were both untradeable then id pick the scythe for sure.

I'd rather have a Scythe!

Got both, but since I dont wield my scythe very often I'd say... Party Hat. :)

I have a green party hat, and loaned my red party hat to a friend. I also have a scythe on various accounts.

 

 

 

Having said that, I would choose the scythe over the phat, since you can always get the scythe back if you lose it.

 

 

 

But, I usually never wear either. On my main members account, I am wearing my red pirate outfit at the moment. :)

 

 

 

I was playing on one of my noob accounts with a scythe the other day. It looked good with full black wisard clothes. 8-)

As it stands I'd get the Party Hat just so I could plough the money into some skills, however if Party Hats were Untradable then without any doubt I'd pick the Scythe becasue it actually looks good :

Scythe, always. If you want a P Hat for money, go work and you can get the same out of it. As for a scythe, no matter what you do you can never get it again (unless of course you already have it)

Definetely a scythe, i hate party hats, along with the rest of so called *rares* dont flame me, i been hating them since even when i used to be in business with them...

Partyhat since I have a Scythe :P

Scythe - I saw a level 12 in f2p just log in after a few years off... He had no clue it was so rare, and then has a mask set in his bank :evil:

 

He aint gonna be level 23 for long - Ironically he was dressed in full iron with helm - I tried to buy the mask set off him for 8m, but had to go :XD:

 

 

 

Wow! I wish I could raise 11 combat levels in just one sentence!

I like them both...but i prefer a party hat because it's tradeable...

i have neighter, but everyones dream is to be rich enough for that blue phat *dreaming*

 

 

 

but i will say scytche, it shows more hounor of beeng one of the ppl played for such an long time, rather than just showing that i know the art of merchanting :S

 

 

 

(myself, proud owner of yo-yo and all later h-day drops 8-()

i got ears and scythe, and i love it

SCythe ftw

i dont care about scythes.....id rather have the p-hat and sell it and get skills up.....But if it was rubber chicken....id rather have that than a p-hat any day lol all the noobs thinking that there gonna die :XD:

Scythes are way more fun then party hats, so I'd go for a scythe. Same goes with bunny ears 8-)

I've got both, but if I could only keep one, I'd keep the party hat. The scythe feels pretty useless to me.

i probermy didnt train combat in the week is was dropped :( i readed about it 2 months later :lol: but scyfes do look kewler then phats :)

I would want a scythe, just so I could show my status as an "oldie". I haven't been playing that long, and just missed the yoyo christmas drop.

If both were untradeable I would go for a scythe.

 

 

 

Normally I would go for a phat, but I would sell it right away to work on herblore, magic and fletching :thumbsup: then buy a cheaper one.

Party hat of course, since it has a large value in game, unlike an untradable scythe. A scythe would only make people think that you're the grim reaper :ohnoes:

 

 

 

isnt that the whole point!? lol :D

 

 

 

looks: scythe by far

 

 

 

money: phat

 

 

 

when i first saw a p hat i thought wow im never gonna get one of those there ugly

I would take scythe, is priceless.

I would want a part hat just to sell and then buy santa and use rest to pay for training skills.

I rather get the phat. not for the money because it look cool... I would never sell it..

 

 

 

~BOMB

I'd take a rubber chicken. But since that's not a choice, I'll say party hat. Even if it was untradeable. A blue one if you wanted to know.

Party hat. I've never really liked scythes.